Why Do Cinnamon Rolls Need Two Rises? The Secret to Soft, Fluffy Dough

Why do I need two rises for my bread dough?

1st Rise- Bulk Fermentation

Introduction

If you’ve ever baked bread or cinnamon rolls, you know the waiting game: mix, knead, let it rise… then punch it down and let it rise again. At first, it might seem like an unnecessary step. Why not just let it rise once and get to the good part—eating?

But here’s the thing: those two rises aren’t just about tradition. They’re the secret to flavorful, soft, and perfectly textured dough. Whether you’re making dinner rolls, sourdough, or my favorite—cinnamon rolls—both rises play an essential role. Let’s break it down!

First Rise: Building Flavor & Structure (Bulk Fermentation)

The first rise happens right after kneading and is when the yeast gets to work. This stage is also called bulk fermentation because the dough is rising as one large mass before being shaped.

What Happens During the First Rise?

✔️ Flavor Development: The yeast ferments the sugars in the dough, producing carbon dioxide and ethanol. This is what gives your dough its signature rich, slightly sweet, yeasty flavor.

✔️ Gas Production & Texture: As the yeast releases carbon dioxide, tiny air pockets form inside the dough, making it lighter and softer. Da bubblessss!

✔️ Gluten Relaxation & Structure: Kneading strengthens gluten, but the dough needs time to relax so it becomes soft and stretchy rather than tough.

✔️ Moisture Distribution: The first rise allows the ingredients (especially flour and liquid) to fully hydrate and blend, preventing dry or uneven baking.

How Long Should the First Rise Be?

⏳ Typically, 1 to 2 hours at room temperature, or until the dough doubles in size.

📌 Pro Tip: The best way to tell if the first rise is done is with the poke test. Gently press your finger into the dough:

• If the indentation springs back immediately, it needs more time.

• If it slowly fills in, it’s ready!

• If it stays deeply indented, it may be over-proofed.

  
  

💡 Storytime: One time, I got impatient and rushed the first rise, thinking, Eh, close enough! I was making about 100 rolls at the time, and I need the time to fly by quicker. The result? Cinnamon rolls that collapsed with no structure and quite a bland flavor. So be patient and let the dough do what it is supposed to do!

Second Rise: Lightening the Dough & Perfecting Texture (Proofing)

After the first rise, the dough is punched down, shaped (into rolls, loaves, etc.), and left to rise again before baking.

Why Is the Second Rise Important? ✔️ Ensures a Light, Fluffy Texture: The second rise allows the dough to expand again, resulting in softer, airier baked goods. The first rise creates large, uneven air pockets as yeast ferments and releases gas. Punching down and shaping the dough redistributes the yeast and gas, leading to a more even, controlled rise during proofing. ✔️ Improves Oven Spring: During baking, steam inside the dough expands rapidly— the 2nd rise ensures that the dough has the right balance of gases, moisture, and gluten strength for the best expansion during baking. If the dough goes straight from the first rise to the oven, it won’t have enough trapped gas to expand properly. ✔️ Creates a Tender Crumb: The second rise allows the gluten network to relax one final time, making the final bake soft and delicate instead of chewy. ✔️ Sets the Final Shape: After shaping, the dough needs time to relax and expand evenly. If baked too soon, the tight gluten structure may resist expansion, leading to a dense or lopsided loaf.

2nd rise- Proofing

Why Is the Second Rise Important?

✔️ Ensures a Light, Fluffy Texture: The second rise allows the dough to expand again, resulting in softer, airier baked goods. The first rise creates large, uneven air pockets as yeast ferments and releases gas. Punching down and shaping the dough redistributes the yeast and gas, leading to a more even, controlled rise during proofing.

✔️ Improves Oven Spring: During baking, steam inside the dough expands rapidly— the 2nd rise ensures that the dough has the right balance of gases, moisture, and gluten strength for the best expansion during baking. If the dough goes straight from the first rise to the oven, it won’t have enough trapped gas to expand properly.

✔️ Creates a Tender Crumb: The second rise allows the gluten network to relax one final time, making the final bake soft and delicate instead of chewy.

✔️ Sets the Final Shape: After shaping, the dough needs time to relax and expand evenly. If baked too soon, the tight gluten structure may resist expansion, leading to a dense or lopsided loaf.

How Long Should the Second Rise Be?

⏳ Typically, 30 minutes to 1 hour, or until the dough has puffed up but hasn’t doubled completely.

📌 Pro Tip: Be careful not to over-proof during the second rise! If the dough sits too long, the gluten structure weakens, and the rolls may collapse in the oven.

What Happens If You Skip the Second Rise?

If you go straight from the first rise to baking, your dough will still rise some, but it won’t be as soft or fluffy. Your bread or cinnamon rolls will end up denser and chewier instead of light and tender. In a rush? You can try a shorter second rise, but skipping it altogether usually results in a tougher, less airy bake.

Final Thoughts

The two-rise method might seem like an unnecessary wait, but trust me—it’s the secret to soft, flavorful, bakery-style cinnamon rolls. So next time you're tempted to skip that second rise, remember: good things come to those who proof!

Have you ever tried baking with just one rise? How did it turn out? Drop your baking stories in the comments—I’d love to hear them!

Recommended Baking Tools

✅ Stainless Steel Mixing Bowls– Love how big these are! I put plastic wrap on top to proof.

✅ Roller Pin – Smooth, sturdy, essential.

✅ Bench Scraper – Helps with shaping and handling dough.

✅Plastic Bench Scraper -Helps lift the proofed dough out of the bowl.

This post contains affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you for supporting my blog!